Content Analysis of Policymaking Process in Accounting and Presenting a Novel Approach in Light of Chaos Theory

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate, Department of Accounting, Marand Branch, Islamic Azad University, Marand, Iran

2 Assistant Prof., Department of Accounting, Bostan Abad Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bostan Abad, Iran

3 Associate Prof., Department of Accounting, Marand Branch, Islamic Azad University, Marand, Iran

10.22059/acctgrev.2024.365218.1008857

Abstract

Objective
The foundation of accounting knowledge has always been to provide essential information for users to make informed economic decisions. However, evidence suggests that the standards derived from the current policy-making process prevalent in accounting fail to be notably effective in providing valuable information for decision-making, especially for investors. The primary cause of this inefficiency and ineffectiveness in accounting policy-making stems from the dependence on linear reasoning. The policy-making process in accounting is plagued by an array of contradictions, disorders, repetitions, challenges, and provisional agreements among groups without a logical and unified framework. This research aims to analyze the content of the policy-making process in accounting and present a novel approach to rectify this process and strategically guide it towards fulfilling its objectives in light of the chaos theory.
Methods
This study adopts a mixed-methods research approach. Initially, content analysis was employed to extract components affecting patterns in the policy-making process. Specialized questionnaires tailored to these identified components were subsequently distributed to gather the opinions of experts. These questionnaires were crafted to evaluate both the prevailing policy-making process in accounting and the decision-making behaviors of accounting information users, especially those of investors. The statistical population consists of certified accounting experts, i.e., practicing auditors affiliated with the Iranian Association of Certified Public Accountants, Accounting Faculty members, accountants affiliated with the Iranian Institute of Certified Accountants, and other experts in the accounting policy-making process, its standards, and the economic decision-making process. Purposive sampling was then employed to select the participants. Out of 60 distributed questionnaires, 42 were completed and returned. Single-sample t-tests and regression analysis were then conducted to analyze data.
Results
The research findings indicate that the investors’ decision-making process inherently follows a nonlinear pattern, whereas the accounting policymaking process has traditionally followed a linear approach. Therefore, as long as this inconsistency exists, there can be no improvements or changes in recognizing the informational needs of various user groups, establishing clear standard-setting directions, aligning standards with user needs, and avoiding crafting contradictory accounting standards, leading to a regressive and ineffective cycle. Furthermore, the use of the chaos theory principles can guide the accounting policymaking process toward a both realistic and efficacious trajectory.
Conclusion
The financial events and informational demands of accounting information users follow complex, ever-evolving nonlinear dynamics. Therefore, integrating the chaos theory methodologies into the accounting policymaking process can facilitate the development of effective standards that cater to the decision-making needs of accounting information users and fulfill the ultimate objectives of accounting knowledge.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

 
References
Aghaei, M. A. & Mokhtarian, O. (2004). Investigating factors influencing investors' decision-making in Tehran Stock Exchange. Accounting and Auditing Review, 11(36), 3-25.
(in Persian)  
Aghasi, S. & joozdani, M. (2020). Application of Chaos Theory in Financial Forecast Analysis. New Research Approaches in Management and Accounting, 4(51), 26-35. (in Persian)
Ahmadpour, A. & Hadiyan, S. A. (2015). Changes in the Value Relevance of Accounting Information and Identifying the Factors Affecting the Value Relevance. Journal of Accounting and auditing review, 22(1), 1-20. (in Persian)
Ahmed. A. S. & Takeda, C. (1995). Stock Market Valuation of Gains and Losses on Commercial Banks Investment Securities: An Empirical Analysis. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 20(2), 207-225.
Akvani, S. H. & Mousavi Nejhad, S. V. (2013). Chaos Theory; A model for analyzing the complexity of Iran's political space. Journal of Political Science, 8(2), 183-225.
(in Persian)  
Ali Madad, M. & Malek Araei, N. (2014). Basics and general methods of accounting. Volume 1, Tehran: Audit Organization. (in Persian)  
Alvani, S. M. & Danaei Fard, H. (2002). Theory of order in chaos and management. Tehran: Saffar Publications. (in Persian)
Alvani, S. M. & Danaei Fard, M. (1999). Decision making from the point of view of chaos theory. Administrative Evolution, 5(21), 12-25. (in Persian)  
Alvani, S. M. (1996). Searching for a model for decision-making in ambiguous and disorderly situations. Journal of Management and Development Process, (37), 1-8 .‌(in Persian)
Alvani, S. M. (1999). Reflection of chaos theory in management. Management Studies in Development and Evolution, (21, ‏22), 38-53. (in Persian)  
Alvani, S. M. (2006). Public Management. Tehran: Ney Publishing. (in Persian)  
 Anderson, A. (2017). The Chaos of Month-End Close: A Survey of Accounting and Finance Professionals. Dimensional Research, 13(43), 1-11.
Anderson, A. D. (2015). The Chaos That Was Enron. Global Health, and the Study of Business, (6), 1-59.
Ashrafi, N. (2016). Recognition of Islamic Urbanism and Architecture with Chaos Theory and Fuzzy Rule Case Study: Yazd, Meybod, Tabriz. Bagh-e Nazar, 13(43), 77-90. (in Persian)
Badri, A. (1993). Accounting information and multi-hypothetical behavioral decision making. Accounting review, 1(4), 63-83. (in Persian)
Bahramfar, N. & Rasouli, V. (1998). Qualitative characteristics of management accounting information and its role in management decision making. Accounting and Auditing Review, 6(24‏, 25), 86-109. (in Persian)  
Banitalebi Dehkordi, B., Rahnamay‏ Roodposhti, F., Nikomaram, H. & Talebnia, Gh. (2015). Explaining Actor Network Theory in Accounting from the Perspective of Knowledge. Iranian Management Accounting Association, 4(16), 119-130. (in Persian)  
Baradaran Hasanzadeh, R., Fattahi Asl, B. & Aboalhasanzadeh, S. (2013). The Study of the Effects of Auditors’ Personality Types on the Report Content. Iranian Management Accounting Association, 2(6), 89-100. (in Persian)  
Barlev, B. & Haddad, J. R. (2003). Fair value Accounting and the Management of the Firm. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 14(4), 383-415.
Barth, M. E. (2006). Accounting quality: International Quality Standards and US GAAP. Journal of Accounting Research, 46(3), 467-498.
Barua, S. & Chowdhury, A. (2009). General characteristics and investment determinants in Bangladesh Capital markets: evidence from Dhaka stock exchange. Finance and Tourism Management, (54), 1-13.
Bolu, Gh., Hassas Yeganeh. Y., Roodposhti, F. & Chaharmahali, Sh. (2017). The model of approach of accountants and auditors to accounting standards and its effect on the quality of accounting information. Financial Accounting and Auditing Researches, 9(33), 125-148. (in Persian)  
Cartwright, T. J. (1991). Planning and chaos theory. Journal of the American Planning
Association, 57(1), 44-56.
Choy, A. K. (2006). Fair Value as a Relevant Metric: A Theoretical Investigation. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 14(5), 1-56.
Dougherty, M. R. & Thomas, R. P. (2012). Robust Decision Making in a Nonlinear World. Psychological Review, 119(2), 321-344.
Eftekharzadeh, S. (2013). From the chaos of perception to the knowledge of architecture; A new theory for the creation of human-oriented architecture based on the laws of chaos. Tehran: Institute of Architectural Science, Simaye Danesh Publications. (in Persian)
Emami, M., Nazari, K. ‏‏& Fardmanesh, H. (2012). Chaos Theory and its Complexity and Role in the Analyzing of Policy Networks (with a Look at Future Orientations in Policy-Making Process). Journal of Basic and Applied Scientific Research, 2(3), 2624-2630.
Enayati Tayebi, R., Mehrazeen, A. ‏‏& Jabbari Noqabi, M. (2022). Comparison of the potential of chaotic models and artificial neural networks in explaining abnormal stock returns around the release date of annual financial statements. Journal of Accounting and Auditing Researches, 14(53), 135-154. (in Persian)
EntezAri, F. & Azizi Bandarabadi, M. H. (2018). Investigating the role of butterfly effect in management. Quarterly Journal of New Researches in Management and Accounting, (15), 141-154. (in Persian)  
Ettehadfard, M. (2022). Accounting Theory. Tehran: Soudemahan Publications. (in Persian)
Foroughi, D. & Yadegari, S. (2010). Application of artificial neural networks in accounting. Accounting and Financial Management, (4), 31-58. (in Persian)  
Ghaleh, Z. & Dastgir, M. ‏(2023). Study the Effect of Institutional Ownership on the Relationship
between Accounting Quality and Cost of Capital. Journal of Accounting and Auditing Researches, (57), 5-28. (in Persian)
Hadizadeh, E., Taleghani, M. & Barari Nokashti, S. (2022). Examining the Forex Market Based on Chaos Theory. Journal of System Management, 8(3), 83‐94.
Haji Karimi, B. (2010). Chaos theory and its application in organizational decision-making. Behavioral Sciences, 2(3), 31-46. (in Persian)  
Hemmati, H. & Naderi, A. (2012). The process of changes in accounting standardization approach and its necessities (with emphasis on the theoretical structure of standards). Accounting and auditing studies. 1(1), 64-81. (in Persian)  
Hendriksen, E. S. & Van Breda, M. F. (1992). Accouuting Theory. 5th edition. United States of America: IRWIN, Inc.
Horngren, C. T. (1972). Accounting principles: private or public sector? Journal of accountancy, (133), 37-41.
Hsieh, D. A. (1991). Chaos and nonlinear dynamics: application to financial markets. Journal of Finance, 46(5), 1839-1877.
Ijiri, Y. (1967). The Foundation of Accounting Measurement. Accounting Review, 43(1), 199- 201.
Inga Dziergwa, K. (2014). Conserved Value Based Accounting Principles: Removing Chaotic Fluctuations from Financial Statements. Doctoral Thesis for obtaining the doctoral degree granted by the Universidad Rey Juan Carlos Madrid/Spain and Hochschule Neu-Ulm University/Germany, Facultad de Ciencias Jurídicas y Sociales.
Juarez, F. (2015). Chaos and Complexity in Financial Statements. Journal of Business and Management Research, 6(3), 1399-1410.
Juarez. F. (2010). Applying the theory of chaos and a complex model of health to establish relations among financial indicators. Journal of Procedia Computer Science, 14(4), 982-986.
Karam, A. (2010). Chaos theory, fractal and nonlinear systems in geomorphology. Physical Geography Quarterly, 3(8), 67-82. (in Persian)  
Khalifa, H. (2019). A Study on Investment Problem in Chaos Environment. Journal of Applied Research on Industrial Engineering, 6(3), 177-183.
Khodadadi, V., Taker, R. & Zarezadeh Mehrizi, M. S. (2010). The role of fair value accounting in the global financial crisis. Journal of Accountant, 25(4), 64-67. (in Persian)  
Khoshtinat, M. & Raei, H. (2004). The effect of providing social accounting information on investors' decision making. Journal of Accounting and auditing review, 11(37), 73-92.
(in Persian)  
Khoshtinat, M. (1998). The effects of presenting financial statements on investors' judgment in investment decisions. Accounting and auditing review, 6(24, 25), 135-165. (in Persian)  
Klioutchnikov, I., Sigova, M‏. & Beizerova, N. (2017). Chaos Theory in Finance. Procedia Computer Science, (119)‏, 368–375.
Kohlbeck, M. & Warfield, T. (2008). The Effects of Accounting Standard Setting on Accounting Quality. Journal of Accounting Research, 46(3), 1-38.
Lev, B. & Zarowin, P. (1999). The Boundaries of Financial Reporting and How to Extend Them. Journal of Accounting Research, (‏37), 353-382.
Lorenz, E. N. (2005). The Essence of Chaos. University of Washington Press.
Mehrabanpour, M. R. & Miri Chimeh, F.  (2020). Introducing the Latest Development in World Accounting Standard Setting: American Accounting Standards Codification System. Accounting and Auditing Studies, 9(35), 59-74. (in Persian)
Mehrani, S., Karami, Gh. R. & Seyyed Hosseini, S. M. (2013). Accounting Theory. The first volume, Tehran: Negah Danesh. (in Persian)
Mei Chen, L. (2010). The Effects of Investor Sentiment on Returns and Idiosyncratic Risk in the Japanese Stock Market. International Research Journal of Finance and Economics, (60), 29-43.
Menti Reshnu, H. & Zarei Majd, F. (2020). The relationship between the transparency of accounting information and financial performance: while emphasizing the role of investment risk. Journal of New Researches in Entrepreneurship Management and Business Development, 1(4), 16-34. (in Persian)  
Mojtahedzadeh, V. & Momeni, M. (2003). The effect of presenting a comprehensive profit and loss statement on the decisions of users of financial statements: the views of users of financial statements. Journal of Accounting and auditing review, 10(31), 75-96.
 (in Persian)  
Mokhtarian, F. (2013). Chaos theory in educational management. School Management Development Quarterly, 12(2), 1-3. (in Persian)
Moradi, M. (2015). Modeling of Earnings Quality in Tehran Stock Exchange: Accruals Role. Journal of Accounting and Auditing Researches, 7(25), 76-99. (in Persian)  
Nejati, V. (2013). Correlation of Risky Decision Making with Executive Function of Brain in
Adolescences. Journal of Research in Behavioural Sciences, 11(4): 270-278. (in Persian)
Ogwang, J. (2021). Some Non-Linear Problems in Accounting and Finance: Can we Apply
Regression?. International Journal of Business, Economics and Management, 8 (2), 81-99.
Plantin, G., Sapra, H. & Song Shin, H. (2008). Fair Value Accounting and Financial Stability. Financial Stability Review, (12), 85–94.
Ronen, J. (2002). Post-Enron Reform: FinancialStatement Insurance and GAAP Re-Visited. Stanford Journal of Law, Business & Finance, 8 (1), 1-30.
Roodposhti, F. & Salehi, A. (2014). Theories and schools of Finance and accounting. Second edition, Tehran: Azad University Publications, Tehran Center Branch. (in Persian)  
Roodposhti, F. & Yazdani, Sh. (2009). Application of psychological theories in accounting. Financial accounting and auditing researches, 1(4), 1-26. (in Persian)  
Roodposhti, F. Hashemloo, F., Dadbeh, F.  & Ebadzadeh, K. (2017). The Effect of Chaotic Behavior Components on Sales Outsourcing: Case of Zamzam Company. Financial Engineering and Portfolio Management, (31), 113-148. (in Persian)  
Sabzalipour, F. (2012). ‏Effect of the Convergence of Iranian Consolidation Standard with the International Standard on the Usefulness of Consolidated Information. Journal of Accounting Knowledge, 3(11), 181-200. (in Persian)  
Saghafi, A. & Baghomian, R. (2009). Value Relevance of Accounting Information: Measurement and Behavioral Aspects. Empirical Studies in Financial Accounting‏, (25), 1-52. (in Persian)  
Saghafi, A. & Ebrahimi, E. (2009). The Association of Accounting Standard Setting with Accounting Information Quality. Journal of Accounting and auditing review, 16(57), 33-50. (in Persian)
Salami, A. B. (2002). ‏Chaotic trend test on stock returns in Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Economic Research, (‏5), 35-71. (in Persian)
Salehi, A., Moradi, M. & Bozorgmehrian, Sh. (2015). Analyze Failures and Shortcomings Related to the Role of Accounting in the Decision-Making Process of Managers. Journal of accounting and social interests, 5(3), 51-67. (in Persian)
Schroeder, R. G., Clark, M. W. & Cathey, J. M. (2009). Financial Accounting Theory and Analysis. Text and Cases, 9th Edition.
Sheikh, M. J. & Porkavush, T. (2007). Investigating the relationship between risk based on accounting information and risk based on market information in listed companies of Tehran Stock Exchange (1999-2005). Journal of Daneshvar Behavior/Management and Achievement, 17(41), 39-56. (in Persian)  
Smith, J. M., Fred S. K. & Stice, E. K. (1995). Intermediate Accounting. 12th Edition, South-Western College Publishing.
Soudani, S. N. (2012). The Usefulness of an Accounting Information System for Effective Organizational Performance. International Journal of Economics and Finance, 4 (5): 136-145.
Tabandeh, A. (1997). orderly chaos. Tadbir, (80), 31-35. (in Persian)
Taleban, M. R. (2014). The Problem of Predicting Revolutions and Chaos Theory. Journal of Social analysis of social order and inequality, 4‏(69), 116-155. (in Persian)
Tat, M. R., Garkeaz, M. & Abdoli, M. R. (2023). Investigating the Effect of Information Display Formats, Visual Illusion and Emotions on the Bias of Decision-Making Behaviors. Journal of Capital Market Analysis, 2(4), 78-111. (in Persian)  
Vakili fard, H. R. & Aliakbari, M. (2009). The Effect of Accounting Standards on Financial Reporting Quality in the Companies Listed in Tehran Stock Exchanges. Journal of Management Accounting, 2(3), 77-87. (in Persian)
Vakili fard, H. R., ‏Talebniya, Gh., ‏Nikomaram, H. & ‏Taherabadi, A. A. (2014). The changes in accounting standards and its impact on the quality of accounting information. Journal of Financial Accounting and Auditing Researches, 6(22), 123-145. (in Persian)  
Velasquez, T. (2011). Chaos Theory and the Science of Fractals in Finance. Financial Analysts Journal, 5(3), 229-264.
Wolk, H. I., Tearney, M. G. & Dodd, J. L. (2001). Accounting Theory: A Conceptual and Institutional Approach. Fifth Edition, South-Western College Pulishing.
Wu, D. & Li, J. (2017). Applications of Nonlinear Models in Contribution Margin and
Profit Analysis. Journal of Business Cases and Applications, (16), 1-16.
Xian, X. H. & Liu, J. (2019). Application of Chaos Theory in Incomplete Randomized Financial Analysis. International Journal of Economics, Finance and Management Sciences, 6(6), 306-310.
Zabihi, H. (2010). Explorying into the opinions, theories and practices of urban planning. Tehran: Jahad University, Teacher Training Unit. (in Persian)  
Zaher, S. & Mazraehlee, Y. (2015). Investigating the effect of the creative role of disorder and chaos on solving complex managerial and decision-making issues in the organization. Journal of Economics and Tax, 1(1), 41-58. (in Persian)
Accounting and Auditing Review
Volume 30, Issue 4
2023
Pages 747-780

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics